Black Canary and Crimson Fox wrestle in muck

The Elongated Man watches on as Black Canary and Crimson Fox get muddy from DC Comic’s Adventures of Superman Annual 4 (1992)

Black Cat dunked

Black Cat gets dunked in “Curiosity Killed the Spider-Man” from the 1981 Spider-Man TV series

Batgirl pied

Batgirl getting a pie in the face in 1968’s episode of the Adventures of Batman “Simon the Pieman”

Suicide Squad members pied

Amanda Waller is first to fall victim to the mysterious pie thrower in DC Comic's Suicide Squad #21 (1989)

Bronze Tiger ducks an incoming pie from a mysterious pie thrower only for it to land in Vixen's face in Suicide Squad #26 (1989)

Lois Lane is the next target on the mysterious pie thrower's list as she gets a pie in the face in Suicide Squad #30 (1989)

Jewelee is another victim to get pied by the mysterious pie thrower in Suicide Squad #31 (1989)

She-Hulk pied

She-Hulk gets a pie in the face from Marvel Comic’s Sensational She-Hulk #3 (1989)

Gwen Stacy slimed

Gwen Stacy and her friends get a faceful of slime from Marvel Comic’s Heartbreakers #1 (2010)

Wonder Woman covered from head to toe

Wonder Woman covered from head to toe in clay from DC Comic’s Wonder Woman #160 (2000)

Storm gets a bowl of potato salad in the face

Storm gets a bowl of “soggy, smelly” potato salad in her face from Marvel Comic’s Iron Fist #15 (1977)

Rogue pied

Rogue gets a boysenberry pie thrown in her face by Gambit from Marvel Comic’s X-Men #8 (1992)

Storm pied

Storm gets pied in Marvel Comic’s Heroes for Hope: Starring the X-Men (1985)